Is an MOT advisory a fail? What it means for next year

· 4 min read

No, an MOT advisory is not a fail. If your result shows only advisories (or advisories and minor defects), the car has passed and the certificate is valid for the year. An advisory is the tester warning you that a part is close to the limit, and that's why the same item often shows up as a fail at the next test.

Pass, fail and where advisories sit

DVSA's categories, introduced on 20 May 2018, set out exactly which items fail a car:

Category Result DVSA's advice
Dangerous Fail Do not drive the vehicle until it's been repaired
Major Fail Repair it immediately
Minor Pass Repair as soon as possible
Advisory Pass Monitor and repair it if necessary

So the only things that fail an MOT are major and dangerous defects. GOV.UK says a pass might come with "minor" or "advisory" problems to monitor or fix in the future. If you're not sure what each line on your certificate means, start with our guide to what advisory means on an MOT.

Advisory vs minor defect

These two get mixed up because both appear on a pass. The difference is in the rules. The inspection manual says that "unlike advisory items", recording minor defects is mandatory where they apply. An advisory is the tester's judgement call: DVSA has described advisories as a non-mandatory part of the MOT. A minor defect is a real defect against the standard. An advisory is a part that hasn't reached the defect point yet. Our guide to MOT minor defects covers the minor side in more detail.

Which advisories become fails next time

Almost every advisory is the early stage of a defect that's listed in the manual as major or dangerous. Here's how the common ones progress.

Advisory What it becomes if left Category
Tyre worn close to legal limit Tyre tread depth not in accordance with the requirements (5.2.3 (e)) Dangerous
Brake pads wearing thin Brake lining or pad worn down to wear indicator (1.1.13 (a) (i)) Major
Brake disc worn, pitted or scored Brake disc or drum significantly and obviously worn (1.1.14 (a) (i)) Major
Brake pipe corroded Brake pipe damaged or excessively corroded (1.1.11 (c)) Major
Tyre cracking or perishing A tyre with a cut in excess of the requirements deep enough to reach the ply or cords (5.2.3 (d) (i)) Major

Some advisories move fast. Tread and brake pads wear every mile, so an advisory in spring can be a fail by autumn. Others, like light surface corrosion, can sit for years. The wording helps: "close to legal limit" is nearer a fail than "slightly worn".

Can you drive with an advisory?

Yes, an advisory doesn't stop you driving. But the car has to be roadworthy every day you drive it, not just on MOT day. The Highway Code says car tyres must have at least 1.6mm of tread, so a tyre that drops below that a month after its test is illegal on the road, whatever the certificate says.

Compare that with a fail. GOV.UK says you can take a failed car away only if your current MOT is still valid and no dangerous problems were listed. Driving a car that failed for a dangerous problem can mean a fine of up to £2,500, a driving ban and 3 penalty points.

What happens to advisories at a retest

If your car fails and goes back for a partial retest, the manual tells the tester to examine the failed items, anything that may have been affected by the repairs, and "any minor defect or item advised on at the time of the initial test". So an advisory can be looked at again within days, not just next year.

Getting your MOT early to deal with advisories

GOV.UK lets you get an MOT up to a month (minus a day) before it runs out and keep the same renewal date. If you had a big list of advisories last year, fixing them a few weeks before the test means you go in knowing the car should pass, rather than finding out on the day and paying for the repair under time pressure.

How to decide what to fix first

  1. Brakes and tyres first. They wear quickly and they're the parts you rely on in an emergency stop.
  2. Then steering and suspension. Worn joints and bushes affect handling and tyre wear.
  3. Then leaks and corrosion. Usually slower to change, but worth a look at the next service.
  4. Look for repeats. The same advisory two years running usually means it's close. You can check your MOT advisory history for free on GOV.UK.

What to ask your garage

  • "How close is this to a fail, roughly?" A measured answer like "pads at about 3mm" is more useful than "they're getting low".
  • "Can it wait until my next service?"
  • "Will leaving it cause more damage?" Worn pads, for example, can score the discs and add to the bill.
  • "Can you give me a written price now?" Then you can plan it rather than be caught out at the next MOT.

Common questions

Do MOT advisories have to be done?

No, not for the MOT. Your certificate is valid with advisories on it. You do still have to keep the car roadworthy, so an advisory on tyres or brakes is worth acting on before it becomes illegal or unsafe.

Can I fail an MOT for something that was an advisory last year?

Yes. An advisory means the part was close to the limit on the day. If it has worn past the limit by the next test, it's recorded as a major or dangerous defect and the car fails.

Does an advisory affect my insurance?

An advisory doesn't make a car unroadworthy by itself. If a part wears to the point the car is unsafe and you keep driving, that can cause problems, so check with your insurer if you're unsure.

Do you get a retest for advisories?

No. Retests are for failed items. But if your car fails and goes back for a partial retest, the tester also looks again at anything advised on at the first test.

Sources

  1. MOT rule changes: 20 May 2018 (GOV.UK)
  2. Getting an MOT: MOT test result (GOV.UK)
  3. Getting an MOT: when to get an MOT (GOV.UK)
  4. MOT inspection manual: introduction (DVSA)
  5. MOT inspection manual: brakes (DVSA)
  6. MOT inspection manual: axles, wheels, tyres and suspension (DVSA)
  7. The Highway Code: annex 6, vehicle maintenance, safety and security (GOV.UK)
  8. Giving the right advice, Matters of Testing blog (DVSA, March 2015)

Read next